|
Probably no one set the tone for the
New Wave movement more clearly than Mrs. Kuhlman. She had a
mystic about herself that could not be ignored. Those who knew
her or visited her meetings became either supporters or critics.
Let’s follow a different approach in reviewing her life and
ministry.
Is it possible for a person
controlled by a spirit guide from Lucifer to actually believe
that this controlling spirit is the Holy Spirit? I believe the
answer is clearly, yes. Satan and his minions are master
imitators. Hell will be inhabited with a multitude that truly
believed that in life they were following God. In fact, Jesus
told of the Day of Judgment when men would remind Him of
prophesying in His name, but listen to His answer, "Many will
say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy
name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done
many wonderful works? And then will I profess unto them, I never
knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity." (Matthew
7:22-23).
There will also be persons in the
eternal presence of Christ whom Satan deceived, who made
mistakes because of those deceptions, but who learned in time,
repented and ended life in hope of eternal redemption. Thanks to
God, Satan loses many of his captives because Jesus came to set
the captives free. Whether Kathryn Kuhlman will be in the first
category or the last is determined by the sovereign judgment of
God and we must wait until eternity for the results. God is a
just God and no one who turns wholly to His Son will be
forgotten.
The Life of Kathryn Kuhlman
The man who wrote the official biography of Miss Kuhlman
declared that she wanted the whole story told, barring nothing.
Jamie Buckingham may have believed some very contradictory
doctrines and certainly believed strongly that Kathryn was a
woman of God, but I do believe his biography of her was honest
and factual. He did not tell a very pretty story. Her life was a
mystery. Many events of her life were shadowed with half-truths,
deception, confusion and misrepresentation. If the righteous or
wicked die as they live, then her death was a proof of her
disobedience and bondage by false spirits. In fact, of all the
mysteries about her, her death was the most mysterious.
Something was wrong or something went wrong.
Mr. Buckingham started her biography
with these words,
"In death, as in life, she remained
shrouded in mystery. She appeared on our TV screens and the
faraway platforms as a fantasy figure — gutsy in her preaching
yet tender to tears as she proclaimed healing to the sick
multitudes. The world, from the Fifth Avenue fashion models to
Hollywood’s stars to the hard-hat mill workers in Pittsburgh,
flooded to her miracle services. On a planet ravaged by
disease and spiritual darkness she represented that one
ingredient without which mankind is doomed — hope. Many were
healed. Others, seeing in her the glory of God, committed
their lives to the Christ she proclaimed. In her speech and
life style she seemed to epitomize the health, love and
prosperity of the God she so reverently served. To many she
seemed almost immortal. In fact, Maggie Hartner, Kathryn’s
personal secretary and alter ego, once told me: ‘Miss Kuhlman
will never die. She’ll be right here until Jesus comes again.’
"But she did die. On February 20,
1976, in a strange hospital, in a strange city, surrounded by
people she hardly knew, with a man she once disdained standing
in the wings ready to preach her funeral. The woman whom Time
magazine called a ‘veritable one-woman Shrine of Lourdes’ was
dead at the age of sixty-eight." (Daughter Of Destiny, Jamie
Buckingham, pp. 1-2.)
In the second paragraph above he
mentioned a statement by Time magazine in which she was called a
"veritable one-woman Shrine of Lourdes." A second biography,
written by Wayne E. Warner, entitled The Woman Behind The
Miracles, stated that people often used monies saved to visit an
apparition of Mary and instead visited a crusade being conducted
by Kathryn Kuhlman. It was very apparent that her healing
services were on the exact same level as a so-called mystical
apparition of Mary.
The mysteries around her life even
included the place of her birth. Her official biography writer,
Buckingham, stated.
"Exactly why Kathryn always
maintained she was born in the big, white, two-story house is
another of the many mysteries surrounding her life. Yet she
never backed down from the myth." (Ibid, pp. 11-12.)
From her birthplace to her death
place, she lived a mysterious life and left a mysterious legacy.
Her Marriage and Separation
While pastoring a very successful church in Denver (from a
storefront building to a congregation of 2,000), she invited an
evangelist, Burroughs A. Waltrip, to hold a revival. He came
back for a second revival and later announced his wife had
deserted him. It was learned that he had written his wife and
two sons to say that he would not be coming home (Daughter Of
Destiny, p. 78.). He and Kathryn had apparently become involved
in an affair. She and Waltrip were married in 1938, but reports
concluded that they were involved as early as 1935. The
following report reflected an eyewitness account,
"Had it not been for a deep
commitment which he had made only weeks earlier, recent
convert Dennis Brown would have dropped out of church forever
after he saw Kathryn Kuhlman compromising her convictions with
Burroughs A. Waltrip, a married evangelist, that summer
evening in 1935.
"‘I parked the car, and my wife and
I were walking toward the auditorium, past the church office,’
Brown remembers. Since the door was ajar, the Browns got an
eyeful, and it nearly floored the new believers: ‘[Miss
Kuhlman] was in the evangelist’s arms.’
"The Browns turned around and walked
away from the Tabernacle, got in their car and left. They
found a new church home in Harvey Spangler’s Baptist Church
across town and never returned to the Denver Revival
Tabernacle." (Telephone Interview with Dennis Brown, February
25, 1992 as reported in "The Woman Behind The Miracles.")
Here is the official report of her
announced commitment to Waltrip made in the Denver church in
1938.
"Standing before her congregation in
Denver, Kathryn announced at the Sunday morning service on
October 15 that God had revealed a new plan. She and Waltrip
had decided to combine their ministries. Headquarters would be
in Mason City, Iowa. She and Waltrip would take turns
commuting back and forth to Denver for the services — 800
miles. ‘The two of us can accomplish far more than either of
us separately,’ she proclaimed.
"Although she had not mentioned
marriage, everyone seemed to know. A ghastly hush fell over
the congregation. All the rumors they had been hearing about
Waltrip divorcing his wife in order to marry Kathryn — it was
all true. Women began to sob. Several got up from the choir
and walked out. Men sat stony faced in their pews, looking at
Kathryn in disbelief. How could she do it? This woman, who had
preached such dynamic messages about purity and holiness. This
woman who had been such a model of decency and divine
compassion. Was everything she had said a myth? Was she unable
to follow the Lord she had so diligently encouraged them to
follow for the last five years? Where was the inner strength?
The power? Others could sin and fall away from God, but not
their leader. Because she had been given much, then much was
required. It was a hard life she had chosen. No one doubted
that. All knew what she had sacrificed. Marriage. Children.
Just to build the work in Denver. But to give it all up? To
throw it away for a divorced man who had left his wife and two
children? It wasn’t worth that."
"‘No, Kathryn, don’t say it. Don’t
do it. Please!" It was Helen Gulliford, standing at the piano
bench, her face ashen, her eyes brimming with tears.
"Earl Hewitt, Kathryn’s business
manager and substitute preacher, dropped his head to his
knees. Broken. Mr. Anderson sat. Silent. That which he feared
had come to pass.
"Kathryn waved her hands dramatically and tried to make light
of the entire situation. ‘Don’t you understand,’ she said
almost gaily. ‘I’m not leaving you. I’ll be back.’" (Daughter
Of Destiny, pp. 82-83.)
Very shortly after the wedding both
Walter and Kathryn left the two different churches where they
pastored. Buckingham says that she sold her share in the Denver
Tabernacle to Earl Hewitt. His book stated,
"He offered to buy her share of the
building. She accepted and handed him the keys to her kingdom.
Like a person possessed, she could not stop what she had
started, even though the weight of it was already more than
she could bear." (Ibid, p. 84.)
Waltrip and Kuhlman continued to
evangelize either together or in separate meetings for eight
years. They reportedly separated in 1946 and never saw each
other again. Mr. Waltrip died in prison reportedly for bilking a
woman out of money. According to Kathryn Kuhlman official
biographers, she often refused to admit she had ever been
married. Writer Jamie Buckingham reported one occasion when she
actually lied to reporters who questioned her,
"Then, just as the contest was about
to hit its crest, a front page story appeared in the Akron
paper revealing that a team of reporters had dug into
Kathryn’s past and discovered she had married a divorced
evangelist a number of years before.
"Kathryn exploded. That just wasn’t
fair play. For almost seven years she had been free from that
old scandal, now here it was, raising its ugly head again just
when she felt she had won a victory.
"When Robert Hoyt of the Akron
Beacon Journal interviewed her, she denied having ever been
married.
"‘We were never married. I never
took my marriage vows,’ she said, her eyes flashing. ‘Do you
know what happened? I’ll tell you what happened. I fainted —
passed out completely, I tell you — right before I was to take
my vows.’
"Shaking her finger in the face of
the young reporter, she shouted, ‘That’s the truth, so help me
God.’
"Hoyt was insistent. ‘We have a
photostatic copy of your marriage application.’
‘If I signed an application for a
marriage license, it was brought to me for my signature. I do
not remember signing any such thing. Besides, I don’t believe
it should make any difference whether I was married or not.
And that’s all I am going to say.’" (Ibid, pp. 129-130.)
She Lived Expensively as a
Pattern For Today’s New Wave Leaders
Her clothing was far more than "costly array" that Apostle Paul
warned believers to reject (I Timothy 2:9). She was reported to
have purchased her wardrobe at the most expensive places and
paid up to $1,500 for one stage gown. Present day prices would
likely exceed $5,000 plus. Kathryn Kuhlman lived in splendor
with expensive art and a life that was close to a movie star.
Her official biography said that she was "enamored of the
Hollywood mystique." (Ibid. p. 262.)
A Dark Chapter
Her involvement with Dino Kartsonakis was deeply criticized by
her staff and friends. Ralph Wilkerson, a California pastor,
introduced Dino to Kathryn. He was called, "A handsome young
pianist with the ‘Greek god’ look. She hired him on the spot.
She introduced him as "Deeee-nooo" with a great television
flare. It was officially reported that she "picked out his
clothes, finer than he could have ever afforded on his own, and
taught him how to wear them in style. She sent him to Italy to
have his suits tailored, put him up in the finest hotels and
financed his record and sheet music productions."
Buckingham said,
"She, in turn, found it pleasant to
be in the company of a handsome young man who could escort her
to dinner, sit beside her on the long plane rides, tip the
porters, and hail the taxis. Her employees in the Pittsburgh
office called him a gigolo — Kathryn’s paid escort.
"Steve Zelenko, Kathryn’s gadfly in
the Pittsburgh office, saw the danger and tried to warn her.
‘Look, Miss Kuhlman, it just doesn’t look good. Okay, so the
guy is fun. He’s light, He’s airy. He’s someone to cling to as
you grow older. But be careful.’ "Kathryn was sure of herself.
‘I know what I’m doing. I know it looks like he’s using me,
riding my coat tails. But I know what I’m doing. Don’t worry
about it.’" (Ibid. pp. 262-263.)
The Mystery of Her Death
While her life was clouded with many unanswerable difficulties,
her death was like a final storm. While she was mysterious in
life, she was a sad spectacle in death. She became involved with
a Tink Wilkerson and his wife during the last year. Mr.
Wilkerson was a regent for the Oral Roberts University. During a
few short months of involvement with Mr. Wilkerson, he convinced
her to purchase a $750,000 Lear jet plane, controlled every
aspect of her life, helped her with his own lawyer to change her
will, controlled who visited her in the hospital, controlled
every aspect of her burial arrangements, kept her friends from
seeing her dead body and finished the last dark chapter of her
earthly life.
The report of these events in her
biographies reveals what appears to be an extremely sad and
sinister scenario. Her closest associates were left heartbroken
and utterly disappointed. They will certainly never believe it
was meant to happen that way. The Kathryn Kuhlman Foundation was
left without one cent, even though a previously written will two
years before had made proper arrangements to continue her
ministry. The following describes her will of 1974,
approximately two years before her death.
"In January 1974, Kathryn had
revised her will. In it she bequeathed to Jerome and Helen
Stern of Portland, Oregon, a valuable painting ‘in
appreciation for the kindness evidenced by Mr. and Mrs. Stern
to my sister, Myrtle Parrott, at a time when she desperately
needed such kindness.’
"The balance of her tangible
articles were left to Marguerite (Maggie) Hartner ‘to be
retained by her absolutely or distributed as she deems fit,
she knowing my general wishes with respect to the same.’
(Kathryn had given Maggie detailed information on who in the
organization was to receive what items from her house and
collection of jewelry.)
"In a characteristic manner she
included: ‘During my lifetime I have amply provided for and
assisted my sister, Geneva Dickson, and her sons, Gary and
Robert, and my niece, Virginia Crane, and her children, Paul,
Collene and Theresa, and for that reason I am not making any
direct provisions for them herein.’
"The remainder of her estate was to
be divided five ways, among her sister, Myrtle Parrott,
Marguerite Hartner, Charles Loesch, Maryon Marsh, and Walter
Adamack. They were to receive five percent of the ‘net fair
market value of the trust estate’ on an annual basis. If there
was anything left over after all five died, the remainder
would be distributed to the Kathryn Kuhlman Foundation.
William Houston and the Pittsburgh National Bank were
appointed trustees to distribute the funds to the five persons
mentioned." (Ibid, p. 299.)
But this was the old will.
"The new will was entirely different
from the one she had made almost two years before. In it she
bequeathed specific and substantial amounts to fourteen people
who were either relatives or employees in the Pittsburgh
office. Among them were Myrtle Parrott, Geneva Dickson, Agnes
Kuhlman, Marguerite Hartner, Maryon Marsh and Steve Zelenko.
Smaller amounts went to ten other employees. The total cash
distribution was $267,500.
"Thereafter the will reads, ‘All the
rest and residue of my property, real and personal, of every
kind and wheresoever situated, whether vested or contingent at
the time of my death, I devise and bequeath to Sue Wilkerson
and D. B. Wilkerson, Jr., jointly, absolutely free and clear
of any conditions or restrictions whatsoever.’
"Irvine E. Ungerman, of Tulsa,
Oklahoma, was appointed as the sole executor of the will."
(Ibid, pp. 300-301.)
Probably sadder than her will was
the treatment of her physical remains and, also, the treatment
of those who had given their lives for Miss Kuhlman. The funeral
was described as following,
"Tink Wilkerson took care of the
funeral arrangements at Wee Kirk o’ the Heather in Forest Lawn
Memorial Park in Glendale, California, and her burial there.
Even here controversy surrounded Kathryn Kuhlman. Wilkerson,
according to Buckingham, ordered that no one was to see the
body but Wilkerson and his wife. In planning the memorial
service, Wilkerson asked Oral Roberts to speak. But Roberts
was unprepared for what he would find at Wee Kirk o’ the
Heather. ‘When I arrived at the chapel,’ Roberts told me. ‘I
learned that Tink Wilkerson had made me the main speaker.’
"Since Roberts had known Kathryn for
only a short period, he said he felt others from Pittsburgh
should have been given the main speaking role. He felt honored
to give tribute to Kathryn, he said, but felt out of place.
"Leaving David Verzilli and others
out of the memorial service, however, was only a small slap in
the face for the Foundation. Within days they would learn
about the new will, a continuing controversy until this day."
(The Woman Behind The Miracles, p. 240.)
Mr. Wilkerson, Oral Roberts
University regent and close friend to Oral Roberts, was
convicted in 1992 by two U. S. District courts of fraud in
connection with his auto business. (Ibid, p. 242.) Since he
apparently had some questionable conduct in business matters, it
is easy to imagine his conduct in the Kathryn Kuhlman concerns.
Was he acting in his own interest or in the interest of
directing the Kuhlman wealth, reported to have been in the
millions, toward the Roberts University and other ministries?
There is, of course, the possibility that all of his strange
control of Miss Kuhlman was actually obedience to Oral Roberts.
Miss Kuhlman was Oral Roberts’ prime competitor and there were
reports of mistrust between the two rivals.
Kathryn Kuhlman And "The One
World Religion"
Kathryn Kuhlman was apparently the first minister within the
Evangelical/Pentecostal world that laid a foundation for the new
unity movement of religions. It was said by her official
biographer, Buckingham, that Miss Kuhlman did not like to
conduct her services without Catholic priests on her platform.
He stated,
"She had a special love for doctors,
and wanted them either on the stage or on the front rows of
the auditorium. The same was true of priests and nuns —
especially if they were ‘in uniform’. Nothing thrilled Kathryn
more than to have thirty or forty Catholic clergymen,
especially if they wore clerical collars or, better yet,
cassocks, sitting behind her while she ministered. Somehow it
seemed to lend authenticity to what she was doing — and helped
create the proper climate of a trust and understanding which
was so necessary for a miracle service." (Daughter Of Destiny,
p. 221.)
She had a special affinity for the
Catholic style of high church grandeur. When Kathryn went to Las
Vegas for her crusade, the following was reported,
"Kathryn had but one pass through
Las Vegas, and she would deliver the gospel with power!
Hundreds of people in Las Vegas as well as the faithful in
Youngstown, Pittsburgh, and Franklin had agreed to pray that
the Holy Spirit would stir the city. Not far away a Roman
Catholic priest said a Mass for the meeting the day before."
(The Woman Behind The Miracles, pp. 229-230.)
Please remember that a Catholic Mass
is believed to be a time when the very bread and wine becomes
the actual body and blood of Jesus Christ. Millions of
Protestants died as martyrs because they rejected this
blasphemous assertion. Did her affinity for Catholic dogmas help
start the declension within the Pentecostal circles that has now
become a watershed of deception and compromise? I certainly
believe so!
"Kathryn Kuhlman was an ecumenist
without portfolio." (Ibid, p. 15.)
Jamie Buckingham further stated,
"In 1948 while ecumenists designed
programs for denominational unity, Kathryn Kuhlman threw open
the heavy old doors of north Pittsburgh’s Carnegie Music Hall.
Streaming through the doors and scurrying for chairs came
Protestants, Catholics, Eastern Orthodox, Jewish, and other
groups, most related to churches but others not. And they were
back the next week and the next." (Ibid, p. 15.)
This certainly would have been
acceptable if they were led out of these cold-dead churches to
embrace a life of separation and New Testament lifestyle. That’s
certainly what Jesus did. On October 11, 1972, Pope Paul gave
her a private audience at the Vatican. Mr. Warner stated,
"Complimenting her on her ‘admirable
work,’ he admonished her to ‘do it well!’ and gave her a gold,
handmade engraved medallion bearing a dove symbolizing the
Holy Spirit." (Ibid, p. 172.)
Slaying People In The
Spirit/spirit?
The New Testament, which is our perfect pattern, records no
events where a minister caused people to fall on the floor. This
particular phenomenon appears, from my research, to have
actually commenced with Miss Kuhlman and a handful of other
healing evangelists. Without question, every great revival has
recorded Holy Ghost conviction where individuals became
prostrate with the weight of sin and repentance, usually on
their face. The uniqueness about the phenomenon beginning with
Miss Kuhlman has been its connection with an individual who laid
hands on the person. In some cases, the hands may not have
always connected to an individual. Usually the person was caught
by those who were called catchers or ushers and they remained on
the floor only briefly.
With Kathryn Kuhlman, there appeared
absolutely no distinction as to who was slain, including Jewish
Rabbis, Catholic priests and nuns, unsaved individuals or simply
whosoever might get the attention and special prayer. That in
itself is enough to forever settle the absence of validity and
biblical support. The Holy Spirit never acts indiscriminately in
His Holy touch on human lives. Second, whatever He does brings
honor only to Jesus Christ and always has deep and profound
purpose. The Kingdom of God does not play with human emotions
and sensational activities. The overwhelming factor is that this
questionable phenomenon has spread all over the church world and
has followed exactly the pattern commenced by Miss Kuhlman.
Kathryn Kuhlman and Her Spirit
Guides
I am personally convinced that Miss Kuhlman was controlled by a
spirit guide masquerading as the Holy Spirit. There appears to
be no other possible answer. Coming to this conclusion has been
a very tough and heart-rending experience. The following quote
from Benny Hinn’s book, Good Morning, Holy Spirit, will give you
a glance at her attachment to either the Holy Spirit or a
spirit.
"I looked up to see Kathryn burying
her head in her hands as she began to sob. She sobbed and
sobbed so loudly that everything came to a standstill. The
music stopped. The ushers froze in their positions.
"Everyone had their eyes on her. And
for the life of me I had no idea why she was sobbing. I’d
never seen a minister do that before. What was she crying
about? It was told later that she had never done anything like
that before, and members of her staff remember it to this day.
"It continued for what seemed like
two minutes. Then she thrust back her head. There she was,
just a few feet in front of me. Her eyes were aflame. She was
alive.
"In that instant she took on a
boldness I had never seen in any person. She pointed her
finger straight out with enormous power and emotion — even
pain. If the devil himself had been there, she would have
flicked him aside with just a tap.
"It was a moment of incredible
dimension. Still sobbing, she looked out at the audience and
said with such agony, ‘Please.’ She seemed to stretch out the
word, ‘Plee-ease, don’t grieve the Holy Spirit.’
"She was begging. If you can imagine
a mother pleading with a killer not to shoot her baby, it was
like that. She begged and pleaded.
"‘Please,’ she sobbed, ‘don’t grieve
the Holy Spirit.’
"Even now I can see her eyes. It was
as if they were looking straight at me.
"And when she said it, you could
have dropped a pin and heard it. I was afraid to breathe. I
didn’t move a muscle. I was holding on to the pew in front of
me wondering what would happen next.
"Then she said, ‘Don’t you
understand? He’s all I’ve got!’
"I thought, ‘What’s she talking
about?’
"Then she continued her impassioned
plea saying, ‘Please! Don’t wound Him. He’s all I’ve got.
Don’t wound the One I love!’" (Good Morning, Holy Spirit,
Benny Hinn, pp. 8-9.)
Her words reveal a view of this
spirit that is extremely unusual. She said, "Don’t you
understand? He’s all I’ve got." Again, she said, "Please don’t
wound Him, He’s all I’ve got. Don’t wound the One I love."
The Holy Spirit absolutely never
speaks of Himself. He glorifies Jesus Christ in His church and
in you and Jesus Christ alone. Jesus said,
"Howbeit when he, the Spirit of
truth, is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall
not speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall
he speak: and he will shew you things to come. He shall
glorify me: for he shall receive of mine, and shall shew it
unto you." (John 16:13-14).
She was enamored with this "spirit"
that came upon her. Often she spoke of her fear that he would
leave her. She would wait behind the stage, even at times while
the service languished for this "spirit person" to manifest
himself. When he came she was electric and performed as the
greatest of actors. Hinn continued in his description of
Kuhlman’s emphasis on this spirit whom she called the Holy
Spirit. He said, "In my church, the pastor talked about the Holy
Spirit. But not like this. His references had to do with the
gifts or tongues or prophecy — not "He’s my closest, most
personal, most intimate, most beloved friend." Kathryn Kuhlman
was telling me about a person that was more real than you or I."
(Ibid, p. 9.)
The Modern Day "Holy Spirit"
There is clearly something amiss in our present day emphasis on
the Holy Ghost. Apostle Paul stated, "God forbid that I should
glory, save in the cross our Lord Jesus Christ." (Galatians
6:14a) Deception is rank as churches talk about the Spirit’s
operation that is so unfamiliar to biblical truth. Entire events
on the church calendar are being planned to promote the
Spirit/spirit and to teach people these new ideas. A cross-less
Pentecost is nothing but the making of a religious holocaust.
Benny Hinn, who upheld Kathryn
Kuhlman as his mentor, states on the cover of his book, Good
Morning, Holy Spirit,
"How do you recognize [the Holy
Spirit]? It’s as simple as that little voice you hear when you
are about to fall asleep, the voice that reminds you, ‘You
haven’t prayed today.’ Or He may say, ‘You haven’t read the
Word today.’ That’s the Spirit speaking, tugging at your soul.
You know Him already, but He yearns for you to know Him more."
(Ibid, cover.)
No, never! The Holy Spirit wants you
to know Jesus more. He never speaks of Himself, but only of
Jesus. Masquerading spirits and spirit guides have become the
hallmark of the New Wave churches. I believe it began with
Kathryn Kuhlman and other ministers and now continues through
Benny Hinn and a large portion of the same brand of churches.
The only purity of the church is the living message of the Cross
and the finished work of Jesus Christ on that cross. It was
bound to occur that the loss of separation and biblical holiness
would produce apostasy. That apostasy is now united with a
satanically-controlled "One World Religion" preparing to deceive
a liberal multitude. This deception will be exposed and those
that continue in truth and holiness will be exonerated by the
Lord of the Church, Jesus Christ Himself. |